Blacksmith Master Tier List: Best Items to Craft

A practical Blacksmith Master tier list of every product family, ranked by gold per hour, material cost and rack demand in the 1.0 economy.

Last Updated: 2026-11-20 · Steam App ID 2292800

Most tier lists rank weapons by damage. Blacksmith Master has no combat, so the only stat that matters is gold per hour of smith time, adjusted for material risk. This list ranks product families on that basis, using the 1.0 economy and the blueprint prices in the official wiki.

The per-ingot profit table→ explains the gold figures behind each tier.

Blacksmith Master weapon rack with finished swords and shields
Blacksmith Master weapon rack with finished swords and shields

Read the tiers as risk classes

S items are safe money. C items are traps that look profitable because their materials are cheap.

S tier: the items that fund everything

Steel weapons. Steel swords, greatswords and the 1.0 siege-adjacent pieces sit in the 300 to 700 gold band with two to four ingots of material. Nothing else converts smith time into gold as reliably once the steel chain exists.

The blacksmith master ingots→ page goes deeper on the exact numbers and edge cases.

Shields. Sturdy Shield and its upgrades use modest metal and sell to the same customers as weapons. A shield rack with three display slots and a full stock is the single best passive income object in the shop.

Jewellery (late). Silver and gold pieces have the highest price per unit in the game. They are S tier only after Jewelry (900 points) and a gem supply exist; before that they are a 480-second craft that stalls your anvil.

A tier: reliable, slightly inefficient

Iron swords and daggers. The bread and butter of days 1 to 30. Two ingots, 24 seconds, 150 to 250 gold. They stop being interesting when steel arrives, but they never stop selling.

Tools: pickaxes, shovels, pitchforks. Merchant orders ask for them constantly and the trade routes consume them in bulk. Low margin, high volume, and they keep assistants busy.

Cooking pans and pots. The Wide Cooking Pan is a trade route input (30 per Clay Pit run), which creates artificial demand that has nothing to do with customers.

B tier: situational

Copper and bronze goods. Copper ingots are cheap, copper products are cheap, and the bronze tier is mostly decoration and cookware. Useful for filling racks early, dead weight later.

Armour. Higher material cost than weapons for a similar price band. Worth crafting for specific 1.0 set bonuses, not as a volume product.

Wooden goods. Carpentry products are the cheapest items in the game and the reason the starting node costs 1 point. They pay for the early hires and nothing else.

C tier: the traps

Horseshoes and nails. Tiny margins, tiny prices, and they occupy an anvil that could be making a sword. They exist to teach the crafting loop, not to make money.

Anything requiring gems before the Gem Mine route. A jewellery order with no gem supply becomes a lost day and a 20% penalty on a timed contract.

Tier-three large ingots without tier-three blueprints. Crafting Large Steel ingots for a shop that sells 300 gold swords is how you end up with 90 unsold items and no wages.

The tier list as a shop layout

Tier Rack placement Stock target
S Front window, closest to checkout 6 to 10 units
A Main floor, two racks 10 to 15 units
B Back wall or upper floor 4 to 6 units
C Do not stock; craft to order only 0

The front of the shop should be the highest-value display because customers path to the nearest rack first. Putting horseshoes by the door and greatswords upstairs is a real mistake that players make because the cheap items are ready first.

Why this list differs from Steam guides

Most Steam tier lists were written during early access, when the level cap, item sets and siege machines did not exist. In 1.0, the top of the economy moved: six Master Workers changed gathering and smelting throughput, twelve three-piece sets added high-price blueprints, and the item rarity ladder (common to mythic) made quality scaling more valuable than raw volume.

That is why the S tier here starts at steel rather than at the best iron weapon. The old advice is not wrong for days 1 to 20; it is simply finished by day 30.

Ranking workers instead

If you want a worker tier list: Master Blacksmith and Master Assistant are S, elite smiths with speed traits are A, cashiers with Charisma are A, lumberjacks and miners are B until their respective supply chains matter, and unskilled hires with negative traits are C — they cost wages from day one and pay back slowly.

The general rule holds across both lists: the best unit is the one that removes a bottleneck you actually have.

Official source: Hooded Horse wiki: Blueprints ↗ — full blueprint list and prices. Official source: Hooded Horse wiki: Shop ↗ — racks and display capacity. Official source: Blacksmith Master 1.0 update notes ↗ — Master Workers, item sets, rarity tiers.

FAQ

What is the best item to craft early? Iron swords. Two ingots, fast craft, steady merchant demand.

Is jewellery worth it? Only with Jewellery (900) and a gem supply. Otherwise the craft time loses to steel.

Do higher rarity items sell for more? Yes. Quality raises both the customer purchase chance and the price ceiling.