Blacksmith Master Best Products to Sell: Profit per Ingot
Which Blacksmith Master blueprints actually pay: sell price per ingredient, the best early weapon, and the late-game items worth their material cost.
Every blueprint looks profitable when the only number on screen is the sell price. The useful comparison is sell price divided by the materials that disappear, and then divided by the smith time the craft occupies. Iron crafts take 12 seconds at Metalworking 0, silver takes 300 and gold takes 480, so a 600 gold silver ring and a 154 gold iron sword are not in the same business.
The item tier list→ ranks the same blueprints by profit per hour rather than profit per item.

Early: Bludgeon (85 gold, one iron ingot). After Smelting 2: Sturdy Shield (331 gold, two steel). Late: Knight Sword (476 gold, one steel plus one bronze) and anything with a large sterling silver ingot.
The ranking that matters early
Restock prices set the floor: 30 gold per iron ingot, 15 per oak log, 15 per iron ore. At those prices, one-ingot items look like this:
The blacksmith master how to make money→ page breaks down the numbers behind this trade-off.
| Blueprint | Sell | Inputs | Net at restock prices | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bludgeon | 85 | 1 iron | 55 | Best starter |
| Butcher Knife | 83 | 1 iron | 53 | Needs blueprint points |
| Iron Goblet | 74 | 1 iron | 44 | Order filler |
| Tomahawk | 73 | 1 iron | 43 | Order filler |
| Kitchen Knife | 73 | 1 iron | 43 | Order filler |
| Tankard | 66 | 1 iron | 36 | Skip unless ordered |
| Wooden Club | 47 | 1 oak | 32 | No ingot needed |
| Wooden Scoop | 44 | 1 oak | 29 | No ingot needed |
The spread between Bludgeon and Tankard is 19 gold per craft, which over 40 crafts is 760 gold, more than a Smelter. Craft the best blueprint the order allows, not the first one on the list.
Wooden items are worse per craft but free of the ingot bottleneck. A shop with two smiths and no ore still earns something from Wooden Clubs, which is why Carpentry costs a single mastery point.
Best early weapon
Once the Sharpening Wheel is unlocked (500 points, 1,000 gold, 6x4), sharp weapons become available. The cheapest is Swift Edge: one iron ingot plus one oak for 137 gold, 122 net at restock prices. Common Sword is 154 gold for two iron, 94 net, and Battleaxe is 193 for one steel plus oak.
Per ingot, Swift Edge beats Common Sword by a wide margin because the oak is nearly free once an Oak Forest is running. The catch is the Sharpening Wheel itself: 1,000 gold plus 500 points is a real commitment in the first month, and the wheel occupies 6x4 that the forge line usually wants.
If you have the wheel, Swift Edge is the best early weapon to sell. If you do not, Bludgeon remains the answer.
The steel step
Smelting 2 is the biggest single profitability jump in the game. Compare one steel ingot's outputs:
| Blueprint | Sell | Steel needed | Sell per steel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sturdy Shield | 331 | 2 | 165 |
| Maul | 214 | 1 | 214 |
| Wooden Spear | 178 | 1 | 178 |
| Kitchen Knife (iron) | 73 | 0 | n/a |
Maul wins on steel efficiency at 214 per ingot, but Sturdy Shield wins on smith time: one craft, two ingots, 331 gold. If your bottleneck is the anvil, make shields. If your bottleneck is the smelter, make mauls and spears.
Doom Mace and Totem Mace take two large steel ingots each for 554 and 505. Large steel means two smelting steps beyond steel, so those crafts consume four smelter cycles per item. They are merchant-order items, not shop stock.
Late game: why jewellery is a trap and a treasure
Jewellery has the highest sell prices in the game, and the worst craft times. A Diamond Necklace sells for 1,933 but needs a large sterling silver ingot, which is three smelting steps, plus a diamond that only arrives from a level-four Gem Mine trade route.
The maths works only when the supply chain is already running. A Silver Bracelet (449 gold, one sterling silver) is the realistic first jewellery item; Gold Bracelet (597, one medium gold) is next. Rings are better than necklaces per material unit but need gems, and gems are the scarcest input in the game.
| Item | Sell | Material | Real constraint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silver Bracelet | 449 | 1 sterling silver | Silver mine (200 points) |
| Gold Bracelet | 597 | 1 medium gold | Gold trade route (60,000 gold) |
| Topaz Ring | 594 | 1 silver + 1 topaz | 100,000 gold gem route |
| Ruby Ring | 1,278 | 1 gold + 1 ruby | 300,000 gold gem route |
| Diamond Ring | 1,558 | 1 silver + 1 diamond | 400,000 gold gem route |
A jewellery shop is a trade-route shop. Until the route is at level three or four, the gem supply is six to twelve stones per day, which caps production no matter how many smiths you hire.
What to put on the racks versus what to sell to merchants
Merchant orders pay a fixed gold amount that is usually close to the item's sell price, plus progress toward the elite worker at every 20 orders. Racks pay the sell price minus the customer's willingness to pay, which drops as your price rises.
The practical split: racks hold your highest-value display item (a shield or a sharp weapon), and merchants absorb everything else, including the cheap filler crafts. A rack with six blueprints and no decoration pulls one customer; a fully decorated rack beside the counter sells the expensive item while merchants clear the volume.
Margins after wages
A level-5 blacksmith costs 120 gold per day. At 12 seconds per iron craft, one smith can theoretically finish dozens of items per day, but walking, heat and cooling cut that hard. In practice a smith completes 25-40 iron items per day in a well-planned forge, which at 43-55 gold margin each covers their wage several times over.
Silver changes the maths: 300 seconds per craft means roughly 20-25 silver items per day at best, and a 449 gold bracelet is 449 minus the silver chain cost. That is still profitable, but the smith is the bottleneck, not the market.
Official source: Hooded Horse wiki: Blueprints ↗ — every sell price by quality step. Official source: Hooded Horse wiki: Shop ↗ — restock prices for ingots, wood and ore. Official source: Hooded Horse wiki: Trade routes ↗ — gem and gold supply volumes.
FAQ
What is the most profitable item in Blacksmith Master? The Diamond Necklace at 1,933 gold, but it is supply-capped by the gem trade route. For reliable daily income, the Sturdy Shield and the Knight Sword are better.
Should I sell weapons or utensils? Utensils have better steel efficiency per ingot; weapons have higher absolute prices and better rack appeal. Sell both, but keep weapons on the decorated rack.
Are wooden items worth making? Only as filler when ingots run out, or for the early merchant orders that ask for them.

